Telecom Circle

The Enigma called Twitter

twitterNobody thought that Twitter would be so successful but then nobody had thought the same about SMS as well. The simplicity and non-intrusive nature of SMS made this paging like service popular amongst mobile users. Twitter brings together the conversation of social network and brevity of SMS to provide super fresh real time updates on the web. Success of Twitter confirms my belief that the future of social networking is on mobile.

Twitter is a free social networking and micro-blogging service that enables its users to send and read messages known as tweets. Tweets are text-based posts of up to 140 characters displayed on the author’s profile page and delivered to the author’s subscribers who are known as followers. One might wonder what can one write in just 140 characters but people have found the knack of communicating in less words and use smaller URLs to share links. It is the cocktail of social networking, live search and link sharing that makes Twitter so popular. There are many third party companies that have made search a live stream of tweets possible (I missed the live stream search in my post on Future of Mobile Search). I do not know if this is an early trend in replacing the hegemony of Google on search as the Google algorithm does not make live search possible.

A hacker in July managed to get internal Twitter projections on revenues and user base which were published on TechCrunch. As per the hacked documents, Twitter is expected to earn revenues for the first time in Q3 of 2009 and aims to cross the user base of 1 billion by 2013. From a modest revenues of $400,000 in Q3’09, it plans to scale it up to $1.54 billion by 2013 with $111 million of net earning. Twitter has far exceeded its target of 25 million users by end 2009 (Refer the figure below that has been sourced from TechCrunch)

twitterfinancials

What is the business model of Twitter that gives them the confidence of not only getting a billion users by 2013 but also becoming a billion dollar company? In this post, I have tried to list a few options in front of Twitter some of which are in active consideration by Twitter.

Possible Business Models for Twitter

Till date, Twitter has raised around $57 million from venture capitalists like Institutional Venture Partners, Benchmark Capital, Union Square Ventures, Digital Garage, Spark Capital, and Bezos Expeditions. With so much riding on Twitter, Twitter fast needs to roll-out its revenue model. Below are a few revenue streams that Twitter can consider:

Advertising: This is the most common business model for any internet venture and certainly is applicable on Twitter as well. Given the high user base of Twitter and the relative high number of tweets, there are ample of opportunities for advertising. Advertisements can be either be on the SMS alert or in the feed.

E-Commerce: I read about an interesting news article on New York Times on the possibility of Twitter offering shopping advice and easy purchasing (Link). The platform is designed in a way that it can offer advice to shoppers and companies do promote their products on Twitter. What is needed is to enable the payment platform and convert Twitter into the biggest e-commerce site in the world.

Monetize Data Mining: Twitter is a gold mine of data and rich information can be taken out of it even without compromising the privacy of the users. This information would benefit the companies a lot in designing and targeting the products to the right consumers. The companies are spending a lot of money on consumer research to be able to get this kind of information and would be happy to get it from Twitter for a fraction of their current cost.

Freenium: Twitter can follow the model that is being followed by LinkedIn or many other internet ventures, which is keep the basic service free for consumers but premium comes with a price. Corporate may be charged for customizing the homepage theme to match their corporate theme or special applications may be developed for the enterprises for a fee. There are reports that Twitter is already thinking in this direction.

SMS Revenue Share with Operators: A lot of SMS are getting generated because of Twitter. Twitter can force the operators for revenue share from the SMS revenues. Though this is a difficult but operators will not be able to block the service due to its popularity.

Revenue Share with Third Party Companies developing Twitter related Applications: A large number of start-up firms have developed applications related to Twitter and are monetizing the services offered by them. Twitter may decide to charge for API sharing when being used for commercial purposes.

Utilize the Twitter Platform to enter into other services: How about Twitter syndicating the newspaper for you with the relevant tweet feeds. This newspaper can be generated on the fly and can be customized to individual needs. Just a couple of days back, Twitter announced its intention to geo-tag the tweets. This could help Twitter to create a customized hyper local newspaper. Other services that Twitter could get into are local search and advertising. A lot of companies promote their products on Twitter an offer discount coupons to their consumers. Twitter, with geo-tags, can make the promotions more targeted bringing down the overall marketing spends for the company.

Valuation: Finally, Twitter can play the valuation game – Get a large number of users for the service and then sell off the business for a large valuation. Twitter is ready to wait for the right price and has already declined the $500 million offer from Facebook

What next for Twitter?

The most critical thing for Twitter would be to keep itself relevant. The trends are set by youngsters on the net and their preferences do change. Social Networking was such a rage till last year but now its growth is in line with growth of internet. Hence, Twitter would need to keep up with the changing taste of users. Twitter currently has over 40 million users but as per Nielsen estimates, the retention rate is just 40% and many people drop the service after a month so the site may potentially reach only about 10% of all Internet users. Another article by Gizmodo points to the fact that only 5% users of Twitter have over 100 followers and just 5% of “loud mouths” are creating 75% of tweets. If Twitter is unable to broad base the usage, it may fail to attract the enterprise customers.

Also Read: Marketing Professionals – Do you have a Social Media Strategy?

Potential of Mobile Social Networking

Mobile Operators & Social Networking

Twitter in Plain English

Print

Related Posts:

Tagged as: ,

11 Comments

  1. I originally reed this article over the Telecom Professionals Group over LinkedIn (http://www.linkedin.com/groups?home=&gid=23013&trk=anet_ug_hm)

    Reading about the article and with some of my thoughts I bet that the SMS Revenue share could be the right scenario, followed by the advertising schema. Taking in account the quota of each posting system (Desktop app vs. Mobile app), the SMS Revenue is most likely to be true in the future, leaving the Adv for the Desktop/Web experience as a plus.

    That was my idea for the most likely business model in the first place, but an idea caught my mind remembering the Celltick platform which is used by MNOs to “sell” advertising which is displayed in the customers’ ME from an applet in the SIM via OTA. Having a huge user base, It could very simple to them to generate revenue from that kind of scenario.

    So, In my opinion, both scenarios are quite possible, being the SMS Revenue sharing more likely for being more “user friendly”, lets say.

  2. Very interesting ideas about revenue generation.

    I am very curious, that the hacked financials show gross margin and net earnings that exce gross revenue in ‘09. Also that Twitter’s first full year of earnings, 2010, shows a total of $140 M. Hmm 140, does that ring a bell? So might this be a hoax? Has anyone checked into this?

    Anyway, Twitter can easily become profitable with Ads, and SMS revenue sharing.

  3. Who to make capital. Nice piece…funny how we’re focused on “forecasts”.

    Some thoughts:

    Advertising – the idea of follow-up tweets behind yours was past around. Advertisers could “bid” for that space. But the review of Users activity is unexpectedly LOW – < 40% retention {after a month}

    Monetize Data Mining – hold off on anything that sells user data, GOOGLE.

    Freenium – OEM the service, an application Corporations can set procedures for proper use.

    Valuation – Facebook offered $500 Million? Please tell me it was all paper, cause if it was cash……

    Twitter's biggest prize is having Fortune 100 / 500 companines finally come up with a plan to make effort at capturing a way to better Service Clients. Enterprise Customers is the Target. When Salesforce.com crossed the barrier and customized their "On Line" solution, Major firms signed on.

  4. My opinions about the potential revenue streams you have identified are as follows:

    - Advertising on the SMS alert would be or in the twitter stream would either reduce the space available for the tweet or would require a second SMS or tweet. It would require high click through rates to be regarded as effective and these are notoriously difficult to attain / maintain.

    - I don’t see what e-commerce model Twitter offers that is not already provided by other means. It looks like they’ve missed the boat on this, at least for now.

    - Data mining raises all sorts of privacy issues. To the extent that regulation would allow this, I can see it being highly valued

    - Fremium is counter-intuitive. Setting a threshold for the number of free tweets will just throttle usage. While this might be a useful cost constraining measure I don’t see it as a big revenue generator. For corporates, why bother customising your twitter page when your home page is just one click away?

    - SMS revenue share would require Twitter to boss the operators into some sort of deal & I’m not sure it has the clout to do so. Operators are getting all the revenue at the moment, why would they want to share it?

    - Revenue share for applications has potential but requires a change from the current open philosophy. However, I believe this would be achievable.

  5. Hey Mohit,

    Really interesting post, off-late I’ve been reading such posts. I also read a survey mentioning “around 50% of twits are garbage & has no use”….

    But, I’m too sure that Twitter people come forward with twitting idea… ;-) for their revenue generation.

    Regards
    Navrang
    http://navrangblog.blogspot.com

Trackbacks

  1. Posts about social media as of August 25, 2009
  2. Posts about Gizmodo as of August 25, 2009 » The Daily Parr
  3. The Enigma called Twitter | Telecom Circle « aneas.net
  4. Twitter Trackbacks for The Enigma called Twitter | Telecom Circle [telecomcircle.com] on Topsy.com
  5. Cross-Culture Tweets – Week 35 of 2009

Leave a Response